[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Over-The-Rhine Digest V2 #804



 In a message dated 9/27/99 9:37:03 PM Eastern Daylight Time, marquis at icx_net 
writes:
 
 << "Everyone" is definitley the subject, "looking" is the verb, "for" is
  the preposition, "a," of course is an article, "truth" is the direct
  object,  "is" is the auxillary verb, and, "them" is a pronoun that
  refers back to its subject and antecedent, "Everyone." 
  
  m >>
 
 the unholy legions of grammar fiends ("My name is Legion, for we are 
many--possessive verb/corollary pronoun disagreement, should read "Our names 
are Legion, for we are many"; less ominous but better spoken, of course who 
knows with that damn aramaic or greek or whatever was going on back then) 
have cajoled and pleaded and finally tortured me to respond.
 
 "For" is not a preposition, it is simply a modifier.  A preposition is a 
word or a phrase placed before a noun or pronoun (except in absolutely 
terrible sentences) which indicates the relation of that noun or pronoun to 
another word in the sentence.  "For" doesn't do anything other than clarify, 
it isn't a relational word.
 
 tim, grammar teacher of ill-repute
  

-- BEGIN included message

In a message dated 9/27/99 9:37:03 PM Eastern Daylight Time, marquis at icx_net 
writes:

<< "Everyone" is definitley the subject, "looking" is the verb, "for" is
 the preposition, "a," of course is an article, "truth" is the direct
 object,  "is" is the auxillary verb, and, "them" is a pronoun that
 refers back to its subject and antecedent, "Everyone." 
 
 m >>

the unholy legions of grammar fiends ("My name is Legion, for we are 
many--possessive verb/corollary pronoun disagreement, should read "Our names 
are Legion, for we are many"; less ominous but better spoken, of course who 
knows with that damn aramaic or greek or whatever was going on back then) 
have cajoled and pleaded and finally tortured me to respond.

"For" is not a preposition, it is simply a modifier.  A preposition is a word 
or a phrase placed before a noun or pronoun (except in absolutely terrible 
sentences) which indicates the relation of that noun or pronoun to another 
word in the sentence.  "For" doesn't do anything other than clarify, it isn't 
a relational word.

tim, grammar teacher of ill-repute

-- END included message